Metal Roofing Vs. Asphalt Shingle Roofing

There are conflicting views on which is the best roofing material in the market today. Production builders would likely go with asphalt, whereas an average residential architect would choose metal roofing material as a preferred choice. It is a subject of open discussion as most homeowners go with what the architect says, or if they already have a personal preference in mind. 

Choosing the right roofing material is important as it protects your house from numerous environmental elements round the clock and through the year. Starting from rain, snow, breeze, storm, UV rays, and whatnot, it is the roof that takes the beating to keep your home and family safe.

Some say asphalt is popular because it is economical, while others say metal is a better option because it can easily last fifty years or more when maintained properly. If you are confused between metal roofing and asphalt shingle roofing, let us do a deeper analysis to make an informed decision. 


As mentioned earlier, asphalt shingle roofing is far more inexpensive than metal roofing. It is arguably also one reason why many homeowners go with it when compared with the price of metal roofing options. On average, metal roofing will cost at least three times that of asphalt roofing materials. 


There is no doubt that the manufacturers have gone far and beyond to offer a variety of color and texture options in both metal and asphalt shingle roofing materials in the last few years. However, most builders choose single-color asphalt shingles that can be boring and dull. The case with metal roofing is no different as it does have a harsh appearance, especially when it comes to residential properties. In a residential neighborhood, metal roofing may not always look pleasant on the eyes. 


While metal and asphalt shingle roofs come with long-term warranties, metal roofs win the case here. The performance also depends on the maintenance and the region’s environment. Most metal roofs can easily last for around fifty to sixty years with regular maintenance. On the other hand, asphalt shingles last for about twenty to thirty years only with periodical maintenance.

Performance in Extreme Weather

Asphalt shingles are more susceptible to extreme weather conditions, including hails and storms. While there are more durable asphalt shingles available, it can cost up to fifty percent more expensive than regular asphalt shingles. Metal roofs are known to withstand extreme weather conditions well and are even fire-proof. Many insurance companies even offer around a 30 percent discount in premiums to homeowners installing metal roofs. 

Repair and Maintenance

When it comes to repair, installation, and maintenance, asphalt shingles are a clear winner as they are not only low-maintenance but also easy to repair and install. While metal roofs are low maintenance, too, they are relatively harder to repair once damaged. 


Both metal and asphalt shingles roof can be recycled, but metal roofs win the case for recyclability. Metal roofs are a hundred percent recyclable and more eco-friendly than asphalt shingles roof. The recyclers for asphalt shingles currently are low in numbers, though it is expected to change soon. 


In terms of weight, metal roofs are the lightest yet one of the strongest roofing materials available today. The metal roofs weigh anywhere between 100 to 250 pounds per square. On the other hand, asphalt shingles can be much heavier, ranging from 200 to 500 pounds per square, depending on the variant used. 

Expansion and Contraction

As per the industry analysts, some metal roofs are prone to extreme contraction and expansion due to temperature changes. It affects the metal roof’s performance in the long-term and its ability to remain water-tight. Even though the asphalt shingles contract and expands too, the problem is marginal compared to metal roofs. 

So, in conclusion, it can be said that both metal roofs and asphalt shingles roofs have their own set of pros and cons. If you’re going for economical, choose asphalt shingles without thinking twice, and if you’re looking for longevity and durability, metal roofs seem to be a better option. However, it can be said that both the roofing types have been around for as long as the roofing industry exists, give or take. So, it depends on your personal preference as to which roofing type you eventually select for your property. 

Contact Jackson, New Jersey’s Premier Roofing Company For More Information

Still trying to decide what is the best roofing material for your home? Stuck between asphalt shingle and metal and just not sure which is better for you? Every home has a unique design, look and feel. Similarly, every homeowner has a unique situation and needs, from budgetary concerns to aesthetics. At Roof Works, we are happy to sit-down with you to help you explore the best roofing system for your needs!